The theatre itself won the 2012 Audience Choice Award for Outstanding Season.
Aurora's production of "Clyde 'N Bonnie" won the following awards:
- Aurora Theatre : Outstanding World Premiere
- Lonny Price : Outstanding Director of a Musical
- Ann-Carol Pence : Outstanding Music Direction
- Karen Howell: Outstanding Featured Actress in a Musical
- Bryant Smith: Outstanding Featured Actor in a Musical
- Bobby Johnston : Outstanding Sound Design of a Musical
Ann-Carol Pence was nominated twice for Outstanding Music Direction. She won for "Clyde 'N Bonnie" and she was also nominated for "A Chorus Line."